Thoughts on Education
for Global Citizenship
Delivered at Teachers College, Columbia University
June 13, 1996
Just as the currents of the Hudson River move ceaselessly, with
power and grandeur, Teachers College is producing an unbroken
flow of youthful leaders who will create a magnificent new era
in the coming century. It is an unparalleled honor to be able
to speak here today at the premier institute for graduate study
in education in the United States, a monarch in the world of
education, whose crown sends forth brilliant beams that light
the future.
I would like to offer my heartfelt gratitude to President Levine
and all those whose support has made this event a reality. I
would also like to thank in advance our distinguished commentators
who will later be sharing with us their enlightening views.
In 1975, twenty-one years ago, it was my privilege to visit
Columbia University. Four years earlier, in 1971, we had established
Soka University in Tokyo. The warm encouragement and invaluable
advice which we received at that time for a university still
in its infancy, is something that I will never forget. Thank
you very much.
It is with profound emotion that I speak today at the college
where the world-renowned philosopher John Dewey taught. The
first president of the Soka Gakkai, Tsunesaburo Makiguchi, whose
thinking is the founding spirit of Soka University, referenced
with great respect the writings and ideas of Dewey in his 1930
work, The System of Value-Creating Pedagogy.
My own interest in and commitment to education stem from my
experiences during World War II. My four elder brothers were
drafted and sent to the front; the eldest was killed in action
in Burma. During the two or so years following the end of the
war, my three surviving brothers returned one after another
from the Chinese mainland. In their tattered uniforms, they
were a truly pathetic sight. My parents were already aged; my
father's pain, my mother's sadness, were searing.
To the end of my days, I will never forget the disgust and anger
with which my eldest brother, on leave from China, described
the inhuman atrocities he had seen committed there by the Japanese
army. I developed a deep hatred for war, its cruelty, stupidity
and waste. In 1947, I encountered a superb educator, Josei Toda.
Toda, together with his mentor, Makiguchi, was jailed for opposing
Japan's wars of invasion. Makiguchi died in jail. Toda survived
the two-year ordeal of imprisonment.
When, aged nineteen, I learned of this, I instinctively knew
that here was someone whose actions merited my trust. I determined
to follow Toda as my mentor in life.
It was Toda's constant and impassioned plea that humanity could
be liberated from horrific cycles of war only by fostering new
generations of people imbued with a profound respect for the
sanctity of life. He therefore gave the highest possible priority
to the work of education.
Education is a uniquely human privilege. It is the source of
inspiration that enables us to become fully and truly human,
to fulfill a constructive mission in life with composure and
confidence.
The endpoint in the development of knowledge isolated from human
concerns is the weaponry of mass destruction. At the same time,
it is knowledge also that has made society comfortable and convenient,
bringing industry and wealth. The task of education must be
fundamentally to ensure that knowledge serves to further the
cause of human happiness and peace.
Education must be the propelling force for an eternally unfolding
humanitarian quest.
It is for this reason that I consider education the final and
most crucially important undertaking of my life. This is also
the reason I deeply concur with the view expressed by President
Levine that while education is perhaps the slowest means to
social change, it is the only means.
Global society today faces myriad, interlocking crises. These
include the issues of war, environmental degradation, the North-South
development gap, divisions among people based on differences
of ethnicity, religion or language. The list is long and familiar,
and the road to solutions may seem all too distant and daunting.
It is my view, however, that, the root of all of these problems
is our collective failure to make the human being, human happiness,
the consistent focus and goal in all fields of endeavor. The
human being is the point to which we must return and from which
we must depart anew. What is required is a human transformation--a
human revolution.
There are many areas of commonality in the thinking of Makiguchi
and Dewey, and this is one of them. They shared an immovable
conviction in the need for new modes of people-centered education.
As Dewey put it, "Everything which is distinctly human
is learned." [1]
Dewey and Makiguchi were contemporaries. On opposite ends of
the earth, amidst the problems and dislocations of their newly
industrializing societies, both wrestled with the task of laying
a path toward a hope-filled future.
Greatly influenced by the views of Dewey, Makiguchi asserted
that the purpose of education must be the lifelong happiness
of learners.
He further believed that true happiness is to be found in a
life of valuecreation. Put simply, value-creation is the capacity
to find meaning, to enhance one's own existence and contribute
to the well-being of others, under any circumstance. Makiguchi's
philosophy of value-creation grew from the insights into the
inner workings of life his study of Buddhism afforded him.
Both Dewey and Makiguchi looked beyond the limits of the nation-state
to new horizons of human community. Both, it could be said,
had a vision of global citizenship, of people capable of value-creation
on a global scale.
What then, are the conditions for global citizenship?
Over the past several decades, I have been privileged to meet
and converse with many people from all walks of life, and I
have given the matter some thought. Certainly, global citizenship
is not determined merely by the number of languages one speaks,
or the number of countries to which one has traveled.
I have many friends who could be considered quite ordinary citizens,
but who possess an inner nobility; who have never traveled beyond
their native place, yet who are genuinely concerned for the
peace and prosperity of the world.
I think I can state with confidence that the following are essential
elements of global citizenship.
The wisdom to perceive the interconnectedness of all life and
living.
The courage not to fear or deny difference; but to respect and
strive to understand people of different cultures, and to grow
from encounters with them.
The compassion to maintain an imaginative empathy that reaches
beyond one's immediate surroundings and extends to those suffering
in distant places.
The all-encompassing interrelatedness that forms the core of
the Buddhist worldview can provide a basis, I feel, for the
concrete realization of these qualities of wisdom, courage and
compassion.
The following parable from the Buddhist canon provides a beautiful
visual metaphor for the interdependence and interpenetration
of all phenomena.
Suspended above the palace of Indra, the Buddhist god who symbolizes
the natural forces that protect and nurture fife, is an enormous
net. A brilliant jewel is attached to each of the knots of the
net. Each jewel contains and reflects the image of all the other
jewels in the net, which sparkles in the magnificence of its
totality.
When we learn to recognize what Thoreau refers to as "the
infinite extent of our relations," [2] we can trace the
strands of mutually supportive life, and discover there the
glittering jewels of our global neighbors. Buddhism seeks to
cultivate wisdom grounded in this kind of empathetic resonance
with all forms of life.
In the Buddhist view, wisdom and compassion are intimately linked
and mutually reinforcing.
Compassion in Buddhism does not involve the forcible suppression
of our natural emotions, our likes and dislikes. Rather, it
is to realize that even those we dislike have qualities that
can contribute to our lives, and can afford us opportunity to
grow in our own humanity.
Further, it is the compassionate desire to find ways of contributing
to the well-being of others that gives rise to limitless wisdom.
Buddhism teaches that both good and evil are potentialities
that exist in all people. Compassion consists in the sustained
and courageous effort to seek out the good in any person, whoever
they may be, however they may behave. It means striving, through
sustained engagement, to cultivate the positive qualities in
oneself and in others.
Engagement, however, requires courage. There are all too many
cases in which compassion, owing to a lack of courage, remains
mere sentiment.
Buddhism calls a person who embodies these qualities of wisdom,
courage and compassion, who strives without cease for the happiness
of others, a bodhisattva.
In this sense, it could be said that the bodhisattva provides
an ancient precedent and modern exemplar of the global citizen.
The Buddhist canon also includes the story of a contemporary
of Shakyamuni, a woman by the name of Srimala, who dedicated
herself to education, teaching others that the practice of the
bodhisattva consists in encouraging, with maternal care, the
ultimate potential for good within all people.
Her vow is recorded thus: "If I see lonely people, people
who have been jailed unjustly and have lost their freedom, people
who are suffering from illness, disaster or poverty, I will
not abandon them. I will bring them spiritual and material comfort."
[3]
In concrete terms, her practice consisted in the following:
Encouraging others by addressing them with kindness and concern,
through dialogue (Skt. priyavacana).
Giving alms, or providing people with the things they require
(Skt. dana).
Taking action on behalf of others (Skt. artha-carya).
Joining with others, and working together with them (Skt. samanartha).
Through these efforts she sought to realize her goal of bringing
forth the positive aspects of those she encountered.
The practice of the bodhisattva is supported by a profound faith
in the inherent goodness of people.
Knowledge must be directed to the task of unleashing this creative,
positive potential. This purposefulness can be likened to the
skill that enables one to make use of the precision instruments
of an airplane to reach a destination safely and without incident.
For this reason, the insight to perceive the evil that causes
destruction and divisiveness, and that is equally part of human
nature, is also necessary. The bodhisattva's practice is an
unshrinking confrontation with what Buddhism calls the fundamental
darkness of life. [4]
"Goodness" can be defined as that which moves us in
the direction of harmonious coexistence, empathy and solidarity
with others. The nature of evil, on the other hand, is to divide:
people from people, humanity from the rest of nature.
The pathology of divisiveness drives people to an unreasoning
attachment to difference and blinds us to human commonalities.
This is not limited to individuals, but constitutes the deep
psychology of collective egoism, which takes its most destructive
form in virulent strains of ethnocentrism and nationalism.
The struggle to rise above such egoism, and live in larger and
more contributive realms of selfhood, constitutes the core of
the bodhisattva's practice. Education is, or should be, based
on the same altruistic spirit as the bodhisattva.
The proud mission of those who have been able to receive education
must be to serve, in seen and unseen ways, the lives of those
who have not had this opportunity. At times, education may become
a matter of titles and degrees, and the status and authority
these confer. I am convinced, however, that education should
be a vehicle to develop in one's character the noble spirit
to embrace and augment the lives of others.
Education should provide in this way the momentum to win over
one's own weaknesses, to thrive in the midst of society's sometimes
stringent realities, and to generate new victories for the human
future.
The work of fostering global citizens, laying the conceptual
and ethical foundations of global citizenship, concerns us all.
It is a vital project in which we all are participants and for
which we all share responsibility. To be meaningful, education
for global citizenship should be undertaken as an integral part
of daily life in our local communities.
Like Dewey, Makiguchi focused on the local community as the
place where global citizens are fostered. In his 1903 work,
The Geography of Human Life, which is considered a pioneering
work in social ecology, Makiguchi stressed the importance of
the community as the site of learning.
Elsewhere Makiguchi wrote: "The community, in short, is
the world in miniature. If we encourage children to observe
directly the complex relations between people and the land,
between nature and society, they will grasp the realities of
their homes, their school, the town, village or city, and will
be able to understand the wider world. " [5]
This is consonant with Dewey's observation that those who have
not had the kinds of experience that deepen understanding of
neighborhood and neighbors will be unable to maintain regard
for people of distant lands. [6]
Our daily lives are filled with opportunities to develop ourselves
and those around us. Each of our interactions with others--dialogue,
exchange and participation--is an invaluable chance to create
value. We learn from people and it is for this reason that the
humanity of the teacher represents the core of the educational
experience.
Makiguchi argued that humanistic education, education that guides
the process of character formation, is a transcendent skill
that might best be termed an art.
Makiguchi's initial experience as a teacher was in a remote,
rural region of Japan, where he taught in the Japanese equivalent
of a one-room schoolhouse. The children were poor, the manners
they brought from their impoverished homes rough.
Makiguchi, however, was insistent: "They are all equally
students. From the viewpoint of education, what difference could
there be between them and other students? Even though they may
be covered with dust or dirt, the brilliant fight of life shines
from their soiled clothes. Why does no one try to see this?
The teacher is all that stands between them and the cruel discrimination
of society." [7]
The teacher is the most important element of the educational
environment. This creed of Makiguchi's is the unchanging spirit
of Soka Education.
Elsewhere, he writes: "Teachers should come down from the
throne where they are ensconced as the object of veneration
to become public servants who offer guidance to those who seek
to ascend to the throne of learning. They should not be masters
who offer themselves as paragons, but partners in the discovery
of new models." [8]
It is my abiding conviction that it is the teacher dedicated
to serving students, and not the inanimate facility, that makes
a school.
I recently heard an educator offer this view: Students' lives
are not changed by lectures, but by people. For this reason,
interactions between students and teachers are of the greatest
importance.
In my own case, most of my education was under the tutelage
of my mentor in life, Josei Toda. For some ten years, every
day before work, he would teach me a curriculum of history,
literature, philosophy, economics, science and organization
theory. On Sundays, our one-on-one sessions started in the morning
and continued all day. He was constantly questioning me--interrogating
might be a better word--about my reading.
Most of all, however, I learned from his example. The burning
commitment to peace that remained unshaken throughout his imprisonment
was something he carried with him his entire life. It was from
this, and from the profound compassion that characterized each
of his interactions, that I most learned. Ninety-eight percent
of what I am today I learned from him.
The Soka, or value-creating, education system was founded out
of a desire that future generations should have the opportunity
to experience this same kind of humanistic education. It is
my greatest hope that the graduates of the Soka schools will
become global citizens who can author a new history for humankind.
The actions of such citizens will not be effective unless coordinated,
and in this regard we cannot ignore the important potential
of the United Nations system.
We have reached the stage where the UN can serve as a center,
not only for "harmonizing the actions of nations,"
[9] but also for the creation of value through education of
global citizens who can create a world of peace. While states
and national interests have dominated debate at the world organization
to date, increasingly, the energy of "We the peoples..."
has been making itself felt, particularly through the activities
of nongovernmental organizations (NGOs).
In recent years, global discourse on such critical issues as
the environment, human rights, indigenous peoples, women and
population has been held under UN auspices. With the participation
of both governmental and nongovernmental representatives, conferences
on world issues have furthered the process of shaping the kind
of global ethic that must undergird global citizenship.
In coordination with ongoing efforts of the United Nations in
this direction, I would hope to see these issues incorporated
as integral elements of education at all levels. For example:
Peace education, in which young people learn the cruelty and
folly of war, to root the practice of nonviolence in human society.
Environmental education, to study current ecological realities
and means of protecting the environment.
Developmental education, to focus attention on issues of poverty
and global justice.
Human rights education, to awaken an awareness of human equality
and dignity.
It has long been my belief that education must never be subservient
to political interests. To this end, I feel that education should
be accorded a status within public affairs equivalent even to
that of the legislative, executive or judicial branches of government.
This proposal grows out of the experiences of my predecessors,
the first and second presidents of the Soka Gakkai, who fought
consistently against political control of education.
In the coming years, I would hope that we could see the realization
of a world summit, not of politicians, but of educators. This
is because nothing is of greater importance to the human future
than the transnational solidarity of educators.
Toward that end, we are determined to continue our efforts to
promote educational exchange among young people, following the
example of Teachers College, which I understand at present has
a student body drawn from some eighty countries.
As Makiguchi stated, "Educational efforts built on a clear
understanding and with a defined sense of purpose have the power
to overcome the contradictions and doubts that plague humankind,
and to bring about an eternal victory for humanity." [10]
I would like to pledge my fullest efforts to working, together
with my distinguished friends and colleagues gathered here today,
toward fostering the kind of global citizens who alone can produce
this "eternal victory of humanity."
NOTES
1. John Dewey, "Search for the Great Community," The
Public and Its Problems. An Essay in Political Inquiry (Chicago:
Gateway Books, 1946),154.
2. Henry David Thoreau, "The Village" in Walden, The
Selected Works of Thoreau, ed. Walter Harding, Cambridge ed.
(Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1975), 359.
3. cf. Alex Wayman and Hideko Wayman, trans., The Lion's Roar
of Queen Srimala: A Buddhist Scripture on the Tathagata-garbha
Theory (New York: Columbia University Press, 1974), 65.
4. Nichiren, "Opening of the Eyes," Selected Writings
of Nichiren, trans. Burton Watson et al., ed. Philip B. Yampolsky
(New York: Columbia University Press, 1990), 50.
5. An Anthology of Tsunesaburo Makiguchi's Works (in Japanese),
ed. Takehisa Tsuji (Tokyo: Daisan Bunmeisha, 1994), 40.
6. John Dewey, "The Problem of Method," The Public
and Its Problems, 213.
7. Collected Works of Tsunesaburo Makiguchi (in Japanese) (Tokyo:
Daisan Bunmeisha, 1982), 7:183.
8. Collected Works of Makiguchi (1983), 6:289.
9. Charter of the United Nations, Article 1.
10. Collected Works of Makiguchi (1984), 8:365.
Copyright © 2001 Soka Gakkai International. All rights
reserved.
|